Skip to content

Guide

Static vs dynamic QR codes

Printed a QR code that suddenly shows a payment page instead of your menu? It was a dynamic code. Here is how the two kinds differ, how to tell which one you have, and how to get your code working again.

By Mark Stoumann ·

Every QR code is a pattern of squares that holds a short piece of text. What that text is makes all the difference.

  • A static QR code holds your actual content: the full address of your website, your Wi-Fi details or your contact card. A phone reads it and goes straight there.
  • A dynamic QR code holds a short link to the generator’s own server, such as qr-service.example/a8Xk2. When someone scans it, the server looks up where that link should go today and forwards them there.

To the person scanning, the two look and feel the same. The difference shows up later, when the company running that server decides what happens next.

Static and dynamic side by side

StaticDynamic
What the code containsYour link or dataA short link to the provider
Can stop workingOnly if your own link breaksIf the subscription ends or the provider closes
Change the destination laterNo, but see the workaround belowYes, in the provider’s dashboard
Scan statisticsThrough your own website analyticsIn the provider’s dashboard
Who sees each scanOnly the website it opensThe provider, then the website
Works offline (Wi-Fi, contacts)YesNo, the redirect needs the internet
CostFreeUsually a monthly or yearly fee

Wi-Fi codes, contact cards and phone numbers only make sense as static codes. A Wi-Fi QR code that needs the internet to work would defeat its own purpose.

Why codes “expire”: the free-trial trap

A common pattern goes like this. You search for a free QR code generator, make a code in a few seconds and download it. It works, so you print it on 500 menus, a shop window sticker or a run of business cards. A week later, people scanning it see a page saying the code has been deactivated, and you get an email asking you to subscribe to switch it back on.

This isn’t a fault in the code. It was a dynamic code all along, created on a free trial, and the redirect was switched off when the trial ended. Complaints to the US Better Business Bureau describe exactly this: one person reported that a code stopped working after a seven-day trial and that reactivating it cost $228, saying the website hadn’t explained this before the code was made. Another made a code for a printed invitation and found it switched off five days later unless they chose a paid plan. A third had printed 150 wedding invitations before the code expired, and the only way to revive it was a $133 yearly plan.

The business model works because reprinting is expensive and embarrassing. Once a code is on packaging or a sign, paying the subscription often looks cheaper than starting again.

How to tell whether a code is static or dynamic

  1. Scan it and read the address your phone shows before you tap it. If it’s your own website’s address, the code is static. If it’s a short link on the generator’s domain or a link shortener, it’s dynamic.
  2. Look at the code’s density. A long web address makes a busy code with many small squares. A dynamic code always holds the same short link, so a surprisingly simple code for a long address is a clue.
  3. Check the account. If the generator asked you to sign up, offers a scan dashboard or lets you change the destination, the code is dynamic.

Your code stopped working: what now

You have three options, and which is best depends on how much you printed.

1. Replace it with a static code

Make a new code that holds your real address, for example with the QR code generator, and replace the printed ones. For menus, table cards and posters, printing a sticker with the new code and placing it over the old one is often enough. Make sure the sticker covers the old code completely, including its margin, so phones don’t read the two codes as one confusing image.

2. Pay once, then move away

If thousands of codes are printed on packaging, paying for a month or a year may buy you time. Use that time to switch the destination to an address you own (see below), so you are free to cancel when the new print run is out.

3. Ask, and dispute if needed

If you were charged for a subscription you didn’t knowingly agree to, contact the company in writing first. If that gets nowhere, your bank or card issuer may be able to dispute the charge.

Get the benefits of a dynamic code without the lock-in

The two real advantages of dynamic codes, changing the destination and counting scans, can be had with a static code and your own website:

  • An address you control. Point the code at a page on your own domain, such as yourcafe.com/menu. When the menu changes, update that page, or redirect it to a new PDF. The printed code never has to change, and it doesn’t depend on anyone else’s business staying open.
  • Scan statistics in your own analytics. Add campaign parameters to the link, such as ?utm_source=qr&utm_medium=menu. Visits from the code then show up separately in your website analytics. Each extra character makes the code a little denser, so keep the parameters short.
  • One link per placement. Want to compare the window poster with the table cards? Give each its own parameter or its own short page on your site.

This is the approach QRCraftr is built around: the codes are static, nothing passes through our servers, and scanning one never tells us anything. If your code is mainly for one-tap actions rather than websites, the vCard QR code and Wi-Fi QR code generators write everything into the code itself, so there is nothing that could ever be switched off.

Before you print any QR code

  • Scan the downloaded file and check that the address shown is the one you expect.
  • Read the generator’s terms for words like “trial”, “active” or “subscription”.
  • Test the printed proof with two or three different phones, as described in how to scan a QR code.

Frequently asked questions

Can a QR code expire?

A static QR code can’t. Its content is stored in the pattern itself, and nothing about it changes over time. A dynamic QR code can stop working, because it points to the generator’s server, and the company can switch that redirect off when a trial ends, a payment fails or the service closes.

Can I edit a static QR code after printing it?

No, not the code itself. But you can point it at an address you control, such as a page on your own website, and change that page whenever you like. The printed code then keeps working while its destination changes.

Why do so many generators make dynamic codes by default?

Because a dynamic code ties you to the service. Once a code is printed on menus, packaging or business cards, replacing it costs money and time, which makes a subscription hard to cancel. Dynamic codes also let the service offer scan statistics, which is the honest reason to choose one.

Is my code dynamic if the link in it looks short?

Very likely. Scan it and read the address your phone shows before opening it. If the address belongs to the QR code company or a link shortener rather than to your own website, the code is dynamic and depends on that company.

Can I get a refund for a QR code subscription I didn’t know about?

Contact the company first and ask in writing. If that fails, your card issuer or bank may be able to dispute the charge, especially if the terms weren’t clear before you paid. In the US you can also report it to the Better Business Bureau or the FTC.